Pros & Cons
Pros
This is a great scholarly work that is surprisingly very readable for an average person. The thoroughness of the author is evident and praise worthy. Very well researched and beautifully told.
Danino marshalls impressive studies and reports to show that the ghaggar-hakra channel did carry a sizable flow of water when the region was wetter. He also brings in what seems like sound historical evidence from texts like the harshacharita which co... Read More
This book is also available in tamil and malayalam. Questions some of the conventional wisdom about the * invasion of or migration to the indian subcontinent.
Indus-saraswati civilization or some such name, from the current indus civilization or the harappan civilization. Earlier danino mentions the historical developments in the gangetic region, where india’s classical civilization grew.
Cons
This is part of the new genre of pseudo-historical literature that seeks to rewrite history.
Highlights
Quality
Extensive research makes this book very reliable
While danino seems to have his sarasvatighaggarhakra evidence all pat down it is the case for the harappansarasvati civilizatio... Read More
I wish paper quality would have been better than what has been delivered
A true historian tells the history as it happened and never comprmises with the truth in order to push his nasty agenda
Competitiveness
An intersting document that is well written
Overview
- How are reviewers describing this item?
vedic, good and indian. - Our engine has profiled the reviewer patterns and has determined that there is minimal deception involved.
- Our engine has determined that the review content quality is high and informative.
- Our engine has discovered that over 90% high quality reviews are present.
- This product had a total of 895 reviews as of our last analysis date on Jun 8 2023.
Helpful InsightsBETA
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
Which i doubt will ever happen
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
At times becomes repetitive which may be all right for readers who are not oriented to the particular geography and history described in the book
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
This reat book confirms that irfan habib by no stretch of imagination be considereda historian
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
A true historian tells the history as it happened and never comprmises with the truth in order to push his nasty agenda
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
But later not spoked about much
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
Maybe in future we will have clear insight with evolving technology
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
Will be waiting for truth to come out
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
You need to be in a kinda focused mode to understand but not much of an issue