Ask Fakespot Chat questions about this productAlpha
Add detailed feedback
Message
Loading suggested questions
Suggested Questions
Suggested Questions
No suggested questions were found
Pros & Cons
Pros
The book is chock-full of interesting stories about mathematical personalities (especially henri poincaré). What math book has quotes from current supreme court justices? A sense of puckish humor permeates the book. The author is one of the smartest p... Read More
In a world overrun by disinformation and sloppy thinking, shape is the antithesis and the genuine article. Shape is a paean to rigorous the ultimate reason for teaching kids to write a proof is not that the world is full of proofs. It really tells you... Read More
Cons
The book is a bit of a hodgepodge. It feels like a first draft that got a stamp of approval by everyone on it's way to publication without any revision or editing.
Highlights
Quality
Thats because ellenberg also provides the whole historical matrix of who came up with an idea whose work motivated it in the fi... Read More
It’s hard to settle for a nonproof once you’ve really familiarized yourself with the genuine article
Amazing insights from what we thought we learned in high school if the reader just sticks with the hard stuff up front
I dont disagree with the thoughts but it didnt feel like the thoughts were as mature towards the end as they were at the beginn... Read More
Price
Ellenberg is funny selfdeprecating and a great teacher
Competitiveness
Moon duchins recom analysis her brilliant way to assess the fairness versus sneakiness of redistricting maps
Once upon a time back in college there was a kid who was winning not just all the awards in mathematics and by awards i mean to... Read More
Helpful InsightsBETA
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
Theres no way to cover all these topics fully or make a formal proof
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
It starts out with a lot about formal proofs so i wasnt thrilled to casually stroll through todays politics
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
I dont disagree with the thoughts but it didnt feel like the thoughts were as mature towards the end as they were at the beginning of the book
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
It’s a book with a lot of interesting content in it but it is flawed
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
I loved the beginning but each chapter afterwards felt harder to get
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
Its partially because the subject matter gets harder to be sucked into
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
For example learning about all of the ways math can illuminate discussions on gerrymandering for a whole chapter was very boring and the math doesnt make it much more interesting
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
A very interesting reading but very hard to follow
Review Count History
Price History
Ask Fakespot Chat questions about this productAlpha
Add detailed feedback
Message
Loading suggested questions
Suggested Questions
Suggested Questions
No suggested questions were found