Pros & Cons
Pros
Poundstone gives range voting his seal of blessing. Instant runoff voting ranks the candidates in order of preference while range voting offers voters the opportunity to rate all candidates based on a scale of 0 to 10. Poundstone has his clear favorit... Read More
Plurality voting is not very complicated and works very well when there are only two candidates. Elections with hundreds of thousands of voters is frequent. And this might arguably be its best use.
The author makes the complex study of voting systems accessible to the layman, and by doing so, paves the way towards a better democracy. The book is an easy-to-read and understand why and how the kind of winner-take-all plurality voting system is so ... Read More
William poundstone makes this admittedly dry subject funny and engaging through anecdotes aplenty. Poundstone is truly skilled at the way he guides you through his stories with gripping narrative.
Cons
This shortcoming misdirects people in the key second part of his subtitle -- what to do about it. Readers truly taking poundstone seriously are likely to end up * their heads against the wall -- and perhaps making them more frustrated and alienated th... Read More
Highlights
Quality
This combined with the assessments of the various voting systems including the opinions of various voting theorists is convincing stuff
So poundstone knows fully well about these deep global problems with the very foundations of voting and coalitions but to widen... Read More
I dont know about you but i sure am frustrated by the choices we have been presented with during the current presidential election cycle
Poundstone gives all the problems with the other voting methods but basically gives range voting his seal of blessing
Competitiveness
A nobrainer that should be implemented for all voting when you pick a single winner ie our presidential elections congressional... Read More
Now add a 34clone34 candidate for the liberal side
Overview
- How are reviewers describing this item?
liberal, many and each. - Our engine has profiled the reviewer patterns and has determined that there is minimal deception involved.
- Our engine has determined that the review content quality is high and informative.
- Our engine has discovered that over 80% high quality reviews are present.
- This product had a total of 50 reviews as of our last analysis date on Dec 30 2023.
Helpful InsightsBETA
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
If the author writes fiction too i’m all in
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
However the explanations are sometimes confusing and it takes work to get to best understand the pros and cons
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
The topic of this book despite being of great importance is not often discussed
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
Org to find better alternatives
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
It is written for a general audience and doesnt assume any special knowledge of math or political science
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
There is somewhat confusing example of what happens when 90 million voters come to a 3 way tie and one additional ballot is added pp2256
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
It might lead the reader to think condorcet smethods dont work well or give paradoxical results
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
They are however vulnerable to strategic voting