Absolutely love these FRYE boots!

Absolutely love these FRYE boots!  Read Less

I went back and forth deciding between 8.5 and 8, and finally went with the 8.5. The toe box seems to be encased with a hard l...  Read More

I went back and forth deciding between 8.5 and 8, and finally went with the 8.5. The toe box seems to be encased with a hard leather, or some other structural material, so it will NOT stretch in the toes, if you have a wider foot. When in doubt, go for the larger size, because otherwise your pinky toe will suffer. A little heel slippage is normal and can be remedied by thicker socks.The boot is the highest quality leather I’ve seen on a boot. I looked at Sam Edelman Penny boots and there’s just no comparison in the leather quality. The Frye is stiff and leather lined; the Edelman was floppy and the leather was soft and seemed like it would tear easily. I’m sure the Frye boot will last for years with proper care. The couple pairs I got were sometimes lightly scuffed/discolored, but during normal use they’ll lightly scuff anyway. And boot conditioner will even out discoloration.My biggest qualm about the design of the boot is that the outer ‘button’ is a big metal piece that kind of digs into your other leg if you sit cross-legged. Or if you cross your knees when sitting at a desk. It’s something that makes the boot somehow a little less than 100% functional. After several weeks I’m kind of use to it but still would prefer a design upgrade.The leather sole is a bit slick, but I guess it’s managable. Walking on slippery/icy surfaces is no picnic in these boots; I’ve slid and almost fell a couple of times in rainy/icy conditions. I wouldn’t recommend these for anyone who has balance issues. I’ve never had a leather soled shoe before, so maybe it’ll last longer than rubber, but I’ll have to see.All-in-all, I’m very pleased. I think the design is simplistic and classic; a truly timeless piece that will last for years to come with the proper care.  Read Less

Usually boots fit tight around my calfs, but these are great.

Usually boots fit tight around my calfs, but these are great.  Read Less