My dog likes them. My pickier dog sometimes turns up his nose. Mayfield loves her charlee bears. We have 2 border collies that are absolutely in love with treats!

Grain-free version seems to have better flavor. I rotate the flavors and my dogs seem to like all the flavors. They fit nicely in my treat pouch and are easy to dispense while we are out and about. They smell like nothing and are not oily.

Great for training and rewarding. The pricing is excellent, especially when they go on sale! My non-discriminating aussie works for them--no problem.

Low calorie gealthy dog treats. She has many digestive issues but these don’t upset her stomach at all. We make sure to load up bc our dogs love them.

Amazon pricing is what spoils the rating. None if my 3 dogs like them. Woud not buy again.

They are not dry as charlee bear's, but moist, and only 3. Oz. Unfortunately, these look like oyster crackers and we're not the meat i was envisioning. They apparently have zero flavor.