Posted by a reviewer on Amazon

However sherlock is still the man he was a loner unable to fully emotionally connect with the people around him

Posted by a reviewer on Amazon

As usual when dealing with a canon of fiction there tends to be some initial distaste at the thought of reading someone elses interpretation of a beloved character

Posted by a reviewer on Amazon

It is not a standard situation for the character and it can therefore be disregarded relatively easily if it doesnt suit the pallet of holmes aficionados

Posted by a reviewer on Amazon

Only jeremy brett ever captured for example holmes innate alienness and his ability to annoy more than astound the average person then i would say do not judge this book until you have read it

Posted by a reviewer on Amazon

There is some unavoidable crossing of modern fiction themes that seem a bit out of place with holmes

Posted by a reviewer on Amazon

Most of what i just wrote is by way of warning to the mystery genre reader

Posted by a reviewer on Amazon

So i went to look for the book to see how close the movie is to it

Posted by a reviewer on Amazon

I am not supposed to be a sherlock holmes fan