Winco Winware 18-Inch ...
Amazon LogoBuy Now
Nordic Ware Pizza Ston...
Amazon LogoBuy Now

Winco Winware 18-Inch Aluminum P... vs Nordic Ware Pizza Stone Set, Tan

Winco Winware 18-Inch ...
N/A
Amazon LogoBuy Now
Nordic Ware Pizza Ston...
N/A
Amazon LogoBuy Now

Pros and Cons

Pros1

Aluminum is light weight and conducts the oven heat very well. This results in much crisper pizza crust coming out of the oven. Haven't used a pizza cutter on it yet, thuogh.

Cons1

They only bevel up 3/8 and a lot less of the pan is beveled. Looks like they played frisbee with it prior to shipping.

Pros2

The stone really bakes the crust up nicely, better than anything else i've used. My pizza crust is now crispy, and i would rather have 3 of these for the money than any one more expensive stone.

This pizza stone fits wonderfully into our breville smart oven pro. I happen to have a propane pizza oven as well that can get pretty hot. Also use a sprinkle of corn meal. Takes a little longer then the oven, but well worth the extra 5 minutes.

Cons3

The material that this is made out of has some kind of chemical leaching from it. It almost seemed like they seasoned it with old used oil. Cherry on top that it cannot be washed with any kind of detergent.

The pizza cutter is awful. Don't even bother with it. You get what you pay for and i opted for this cheapo rather than fork out $45 to replace my pampered chef stone that broke after 20 years. Cheapo.

The metal holder is useless since an oven mitt cannot fit in between it. It smokes like it's going to burst into flames at 300 degrees.

See all Pros and Cons +

Review grade

A
B
C
D
F

Reliable reviews you can trust

A
B
C
D
F

Reliable reviews you can trust

Ratings

Pricing History

$17.08

Loading...
Loading...

$17.08

$18.01

$11.31

Loading...
Loading...

$18.01

$11.31

Trusted Deals