Gerber Unisex Baby 8-Piece and 9... vs Bumkins Waterproof Splat Mat, Gr...

Perfect size for a newborn as small as 5 pounds and up. I’ll be interested to see if they last more than a month before my baby outgrows them.

This set is the cutest thing you've ever seen. Material is very soft to the touch, washes very well. They’re soft and stretchy, but the quality is a little sub-par.

They fit like turned down bowl on the kids head. The elastic on the mittens have no elasticity. The fabric shrinks after washing and drying.

It is waterproof and easy to wipe clean. It wipes off very easily, and dries quick enough to use at every meal. It is easy to either sweep of or wipe up.

This one is sturdy enough that my chair wheels can run right over it. This mat is well sized for the space we have.

Lightweight material but still durable. It also seems durable enough to last a long time - i'm not worried about stepping on it and ripping it.

Super thin and silky material. Because there's no padding you can breathe hard and the side will fold over.

Splat mat is very flimsy and low quality. It wipes up nicely, but again, not waterproof at all. The only upside to this one is that it is machine washable and can be dried.