NEW! Fakespot Chat is live. 

Get answers to your product questions here.
Birthday Cake Gourmet ...
Amazon LogoBuy Now
Valentines Day Cookies...
Amazon LogoBuy Now

Birthday Cake Gourmet Flavored C... vs Valentines Day Cookies - Gourmet...

Birthday Cake Gourmet ...
$7.70
Amazon LogoBuy Now
Valentines Day Cookies...
N/A
Amazon LogoBuy Now

Pros and Cons

Pros2

This cotton candy is absolutely delicious. It melts in your mouth and tastes heavenly. Strong pizza flavor adds to the value of the good-natured pranking.

Bought as a gag gift for 6 and 8 yr. Nice container. Next day its a my local grocery store for a 15th of the cost.

Cons2

Smells like a 1980s dill pickle scratch-n-sniff. A weird chemically, burnt, nothing like pickle flavor. Arrived all melted at the bottom.

Don’t waste your money. Expensive price for poor business. Very small amount for the $10 price. Save your money. Complete waste of money.

Pros3

They taste amazing and fresh the oreo had a great crunch and they are reallyyyyy beautiful! They are a little dry and crumble easily, but they are fresh and tasty. Very rich and flavorful almost reminiscent of a brownie.

The packaging is adorable and you can reuse the box & now if you want. The box is nice but unremarkable and comes with a ribbon around it. Nicely packaged with a box top for when it's opened.

Great for a valentine's gift. A bit pricey for what you receive, but since it's holiday themed for valentines day, the cost is higher. This is a artisan type collection so that will come down to your own judgement.

Cons1

These are just oreos dipped in chocolate with sprinkles. For the price they charge, this is unacceptable. Could have done the same thing for $7. Not worth the calories.

See all Pros and Cons +

Review grade

A
B
C
D
F

Very reliable reviews you can trust

A
B
C
D
F

Mostly unreliable reviews. Do more research before proceeding

Ratings

Pricing History

$7.70

Loading...
Loading...

$7.70

$15.99

Loading...
Loading...

$15.99

Trusted Deals