What does this mean?Highlights
Quality
Love this product and the tip is very easy to use doesn’t create a thick line
Fine or thicker lines are easy and it will last all day long
This used to be one of the best eyeliners but now it smudges and runs off completely with minutes of putting it on
The last 2 liners ive bought have been dried up and barely flow any ink
Price
I paid over 30 bucks for 2 days of eyeliner its just ridiculous
20 is just too much for 3 weeks of use
Disappointing for the price point in my opinion
If i’m paying 25 for an eyeliner i need it to last more than a few weeks
Packaging/appearance
It was dripping out and unfortunately i lost a lot of product i wish there was a way with the packaging to prevent this someho... Read More
Both were completely dried out new right out of the box
What is interesting is that it looks like old packaging
Now the packaging looks brand new but the product is dry
Competitiveness
Ive tried so many other liquid liners over the years including stila but i always go back to this one
I compare this to another popular brand at sephora and the other has way better staying power
After kat von d sold the makeup line the formula did change to cheaper products
Overview
- How are reviewers describing this item?
last, dry, dried, easy and best. - The most common age group for the reviews is 18to24
- This product has a moderate number of reviews provided by VIB and ROUGE Beauty Insiders
- Below is a list of the groups with the highest percentage positive reviews for each of the following attributes:
- Eye color: hazel
- Skin tone: fairlight
- Skin type: dry
- Hair color: red
- Our engine has detected that Sephora has altered, modified or removed reviews from this listing. We approximate total reviews altered up to 28.
- Previous analysis of this listing was an D grade.
- Our engine has profiled the reviewer patterns and has determined that there is high deception involved.
- Below is a list of the groups with the highest percentage negative reviews for each of the following attributes:
- Eye color: green
- Skin tone: light
- Skin type: oily
- Hair color: brunette
- Our engine has analyzed and discovered that 57.7% of the reviews are reliable.
- This product had a total of 22,026 reviews as of our last analysis date on Apr 10 2024.
Helpful InsightsBETA
Posted by a reviewer on Sephora
Like other reviewers are saying this product is not what it used to be
Posted by a reviewer on Sephora
Now i feel like you get about two uses out of it before it dries up
Posted by a reviewer on Sephora
I have been using this eyeliner for over 10 years but its not the same
Posted by a reviewer on Sephora
The last 2 liners ive bought have been dried up and barely flow any ink
Posted by a reviewer on Sephora
If i did get any ink out it would smudge and wear off within a half hour
Posted by a reviewer on Sephora
I remember having a mini size and it lasted for what seemed like forever
Posted by a reviewer on Sephora
For about 2 years now i’ve noticed that the tip dries up way too quickly
Posted by a reviewer on Sephora
After looking at my sephora purchases i’ve been purchasing one almost every single month and i’m fed up
