NEW! Fakespot Chat is live. 

Get answers to your product questions here.

This analysis is outdated. Please reanalyze.

Ask Fakespot Chat questions about this productAlpha

Initializing Fakespot Chat

error

System error,

Loading suggested questions

Suggested Questions

athena-arrow

Suggested Questions

No suggested questions were found

Please note: The content is generated by an AI language model based on reviews. We are constantly improving the accuracy, however, its outputs may contain errors or offensive content from certain reviews. Please report any errors or offensive content to us. Also, please note that we will not collect your questions unless you click the thumbs up/down button to provide feedback. The answers displayed will be stored by us so if another Fakespotter asks a similar question we can provide them an answer faster. Your feedback will only help us make Fakespot Chat better! By using Fakespot Chat, you agree to Fakespot's terms of use and privacy notice.

Pros & Cons

The AI used to provide these results are constantly improving. These results might change.

Pros

I admit the similes and the metaphors got a bit cumbersome, but then i got past that and started to love them again. The descriptions are rich to the point i felt i could smell them. The main characters are all well formed.

The thrill and trepidation of trying to impress the object of such longing. The other thing that amazes me is that she transports us to the 60s.

Every phrase, every sentence bears the mark of careful, thoughtful crafting. Congratulations on sustaining this level of literary intensity throughout the novel. The audio is well-performed and deeply credible.



Cons

Despite the captivating prose, it therefore means it's going to feel yucky. The author uses language in a way that some might think is beautiful, but it is monotonous.

This is drivel and nonsense. The publishers need to recoup the ridiculous book deal they gave the author for this. I no longer trust books which have won unheard of awards.

The girls' is a poor retelling of the manson family murders. The cult itself merely serves as a backdrop to a simple story of teenage infatuation. It's hard to believe that a 14 year old socially pressured into giving an older man a * would walk away ...  Read More

Emma cline is not a skilled storyteller. Cline drops her character, evie, * into the middle of the spahn ranch (or its pointlessly fictitious equivalent) and the kid somehow fails to develop as a character.

Was this feature helpful?

Highlights

The AI used to provide these results are constantly improving. These results might change.

Quality


I felt deeply uncomfortable at times with the raw reality of the story


Cline has an uncanny understanding of the girls and not just the ones who live on the ranch with the enigmatic russell

Competitiveness


The girls tells the story of evie a 14year old who is experiencing typical teenage problems


I had a 360degree view of what was happening but the truth was dull and muted

Overview

  • How are reviewers describing this item?
    good, young and novel.
  • Our engine has profiled the reviewer patterns and has determined that there is minimal deception involved.
  • Our engine has determined that the review content quality is high and informative.
  • Our engine has discovered that over 90% high quality reviews are present.
  • This product had a total of 3,499 reviews as of our last analysis date on Jun 24 2022.

Helpful InsightsBETA

The AI used to provide these results are constantly improving. These results might change.

    Posted by a reviewer on Amazon

    Although i suppose if it had been a retelling of the manson story exactly as it happened it would have been boring


    Posted by a reviewer on Amazon

    This novel gives it readers a look into a side of cult life we never seeand that is the aftermath of what happens


    Posted by a reviewer on Amazon

    They felt like paper cutouts of ‘60s hippies


    Posted by a reviewer on Amazon

    In fact the main plot being set in the ‘60s didn’t come alive for me either the setting was so culturally transparent that it could have taken place in nearly any time frame at all


    Posted by a reviewer on Amazon

    In short evie doesn’t seem to feel very much either as a teen or as a reminiscing mature woman


    Posted by a reviewer on Amazon

    I didn’t read your novel because it bore a resemblance to charles manson and his bunch


    Posted by a reviewer on Amazon

    A great comingofage story has legs of its own as witness the strength of it throughout all of literature candide portrait of the artist as a young man the catcher in the rye – you get the idea


    Posted by a reviewer on Amazon

    I think you became so enamored of your elegant word choices turns of phrase similes and metaphors that you found it difficult to pull your writing sights back to the plot level

Review Count History
Loading...
Price History
Loading...

Ask Fakespot Chat questions about this productAlpha

Initializing Fakespot Chat

error

System error,

Loading suggested questions

Suggested Questions

athena-arrow

Suggested Questions

No suggested questions were found

Please note: The content is generated by an AI language model based on reviews. We are constantly improving the accuracy, however, its outputs may contain errors or offensive content from certain reviews. Please report any errors or offensive content to us. Also, please note that we will not collect your questions unless you click the thumbs up/down button to provide feedback. The answers displayed will be stored by us so if another Fakespotter asks a similar question we can provide them an answer faster. Your feedback will only help us make Fakespot Chat better! By using Fakespot Chat, you agree to Fakespot's terms of use and privacy notice.