Pros & Cons
Pros
The silicone lid is beyond excellent. The cover on this tray prevents leakage as the water freezes and keeps the ice fresh. My freezer is mid-size, so i notice the slightly larger footprint than a regular tray, but i do get covered ice.
Since the ice slots are rounded, all you have to do is press on one of the edges, and the cube rotates out. Easy to remove from tray.
The only downside is that this tray is pricey. This tray solves a couple of easy storage that doesn't have to remain flat, and easy extrication of the cubes from the tray.
Cons
The ice cubes are small and not easy to remove from the oversized tray. Forget about placing it on its side or vertically. Other than that, it is just an expensive ice cube tray.
The silicone cover absorbs odors from your fridge/freezer which makes the ice smell and taste *.
Highlights
Quality
Best ice cube tray i have every used
Easy to use does not leak and i can stack other stuff in the freezer on top of it
This becomes leakproof if you press down on the cover to squeeze the excess air out and form a tight seal
Bought 4 different type of cube tray no good even 45 stars in review …
Price
Definitely want another one just holding off because of the price right now
I thought it was expensive for an ice tray
The price may seem a bit high for an ice cube tray but in my case its worth every dollar
Packaging/appearance
My freezer is always jam packed so knowing that i can throw it in there and it won’t leak everywhere is awesome
Oxo does come up with some neat stuff but when i first opened the box i was initially a bit put off with this tray as it was so... Read More
Competitiveness
This ice tray works very well compared to others i have
I actually bought mine at winners but it is the exact same tray
Overview
- How are reviewers describing this item?
easy, great, good and best. - Our engine has profiled the reviewer patterns and has determined that there is minimal deception involved.
- Our engine has detected that Amazon has altered, modified or removed reviews from this listing. We approximate total reviews altered up to 665.
- Our engine has discovered that over 90% high quality reviews are present.
- This product had a total of 6,096 reviews as of our last analysis date on Jan 20 2024.
Helpful InsightsBETA
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
Just give the tray one small twist and push the cube with your finger and it pops right out easily
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
From time to time they need to be replaced as the trays do eventually crack
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
I will never use another ice cube tray again
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
When i first got this tray i thought it was a joke saying it was spill proof but i had to try it to be sure
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
I filled it up right to the top put the cover back over the top ran my hand across it like the review i had referenced said then tilted it 45 degrees toward the bottom corner opposite the handle to drain excess water out of the channel
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
Taste free ice even if stored for a longer time
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
Never thought i would pay 20 for an ice cube tray but i decided to try one since i love the oxo brand
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
Weve had it for a week and my kids havent spilled any water into my freezer