Ask Fakespot Chat questions about this productAlpha
Add detailed feedback
Message
Loading suggested questions
Suggested Questions
Suggested Questions
No suggested questions were found
Pros & Cons
Pros
The book parallels the original as well as it possibly could, although does get off track towards the end. It mirrors the overall tone and diction of the original. It's funny and a total page turner. It’s clever in a way i wasn't expecting.
Some plot and character threads proceed as expected, some take some unlooked-for twists and turns. Would have been 5 but for a too drawn-out tacked-on ending. Just an absolute spot on contemporary counterpart.
Curtis sittenfeld is a genius. Which is what kept me hooked till the very end. It’s very well done.
In this modern retelling, the girls are grownup and jane and elizabeth live in new york. When their father has a health scare, they return to their childhood home in cincinnati to help and discover that the sprawling tudor they grew up in is crumbling... Read More
Chip bingley is a neurosurgeon in cincinnati. His friend, fitzwilliam darcy, is also a neurosurgen. Both are married with children.
Cons
I was never sold on the romance between jane and bingley or liz and darcy. One dull semi-sarcastically, liz asked darcy, are you a regular here? Why does william collins still kiss lizzy and propose marriage even though they’re step-cousins? The autho... Read More
Liz is not so sensible, and she has morphed into the family fixer. Hardly intelligent and witty repartee.
Curtis sittenfeld is probably the most overrated writer in the us today. This author is no jane austen. Perhaps in austen times, there was a different understanding of wit and impertinent.
The author attempts a cheap mimicry and her embarrassing endeavor to write satire results in a tragedy.
Highlights
Quality
It mirrors the overall tone and diction of the original as well
Great characters and fun insertions of today’s issues and generational differences
There were soooo many assumptions she made and it became quite frustrating to read… as it delayed action taking place
Im sorry it languished on my tbr pile for so long
Price
This cost me about half what the library would have charged
Overview
- How are reviewers describing this item?
modern and loved. - Our engine has profiled the reviewer patterns and has determined that there is high deception involved.
- Our engine has analyzed and discovered that 44.0% of the reviews are reliable.
- This product had a total of 12,871 reviews as of our last analysis date on Jan 29 2024.
Helpful InsightsBETA
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
Okay that being said i fall into the category of many women who can say pride and prejudice is one of their all time favorite novels
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
Rarely do i read some new information that makes me view the original novel in any different way
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
To take characters that to me are so mild and sometimes bland in retellings and truly update them into characters i not only understood but related to while keeping their original integrity and truly bringing jane austen’s story to life quite literary reopened my eyes to what a ground breaking and phenomenal novel pp is
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
For example in pp lydia is annoying spoiled and self centered with zero filter
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
She’s downright scandalous with her self centered cruel and selfish behavior
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
The same goes for mrs bennet
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
And not the same ages at the originals
Posted by a reviewer on Amazon
I wanted something smart and romantic and it more than delivered
Review Count History
Price History
Ask Fakespot Chat questions about this productAlpha
Add detailed feedback
Message
Loading suggested questions
Suggested Questions
Suggested Questions
No suggested questions were found