NINE WEST Footwear Wom...
Amazon LogoBuy Now
Cole Haan Women's Menl...
Amazon LogoBuy Now

NINE WEST Footwear Women's ASTOR... vs Cole Haan Women's Menlo Skimmer ...

NINE WEST Footwear Women's ASTORIA9X9 Fabric

$46.98
Amazon LogoBuy Now

Cole Haan Women's Menlo Skimmer Pump

$76.46
Amazon LogoBuy Now
Pros and Cons
Pros3

They are true to size and the chunky heel provide a lot of balance. I have to get 1/2 size up because the toe box is a little narrow for me.

The leather is reasonably soft and will probably mould a little over time. They are comfortable and a pretty shoe.

Amazing, * shoe. Only reason i gave these 4stars is because the 2nd time i ordered them, there is a piece of silver hardware on the back of the shoe, which my airline doesn't allow. Still love the shoe though.

Cons1

There is no cushioning to support it as the heel is higher than expected. The inner sole of one of the shoes keeps sliding so it’s hurting my foot. The shoe size runs very small.

Pros1

These are lightweight, low to the ground, comfortable and work well for a professional setting. I get a lot of compliments of how cute these shoes are. The quality of the shoe is really good too.

Cons1

These are way to short and narrow. I’m a true size 7 and these are way.

See all Pros and Cons +
Review grade
A
B
C
D
F

Mostly unreliable reviews. Do more research before proceeding

A
B
C
D
F

Unreliable Reviews. Do more research before proceeding

Ratings
Pricing History

$46.98

Loading...
Loading...

$46.98

$76.46

Loading...
Loading...

$76.46

Trusted Deals