MY MIRONEY 1.5" Door Hinges Cabi... vs AmazonBasics Rounded 3.5" x 3.5"...

These are a great deal. They are solid and weather proof.

They match schlage antique brass doorknobs really well. Trailed others in finish and hinge action. It is easy to overlook the state of your doors' hinges.

After reviewing reviews, i see this has been an issue for a couple of years. It's just another bait for amazon to make a quick buck off of terribly designed products.

The hinges look nice and sturdy, but the hinge pin seems to be covered with adhesive or other sticky substance rather than oil. Lot of scratches and dings on at least one side of the hinge.

They are very stiff, emit a crunchy sound when opened/closed and are not matte black. Right out of the package, the pin is nearly impossible to remove. I resorted to a small screwdriver to the bottom of the pin and a hammer to get it out.

These are nice looking; however, they are worthless pieces of junk. Ended up returning these after installing on 4 doors.